Larry Kuperman thought he had found his permanent home. As GameStop's head of electronic distribution on the PC side, he was building Impulse, a platform designed to compete directly with Steam. Then GameStop's leadership made a call that, in hindsight, ranks among the most costly miscalculations in retail gaming history.
The retailer decided digital distribution was "a passing phase." Brick and mortar, they believed, would come roaring back. Kuperman, who shared this story at the Game Developers Conference, put it bluntly: "I've seen the future, it looks just like the 1950s." That future never arrived.
From Stardock to a Steam challenger nobody remembers
The story of Impulse actually starts well before GameStop got involved. Kuperman joined Stardock, a software company branching into games, back in 2001. The team was already thinking about digital distribution at a time when most of the industry wasn't paying attention.
His first project there involved negotiating electronic distribution rights for an economics sim called The Corporate Machine. The Take Two lawyer on the other side of that deal reportedly didn't care much about the clause. Digital sales seemed like a footnote. That footnote would eventually become the entire chapter.
Around 2004 to 2005, Canadian publisher Strategy First (known for Jagged Alliance) collapsed while working with Stardock. Stardock walked away from that situation with electronic distribution rights to Strategy First's catalogue. That library became the foundation for what would eventually launch as Impulse in 2008.
The platform was, by Kuperman's own description, a similar setup to Steam: a digital storefront with a client, a catalogue, and the infrastructure to sell PC games online. It wasn't trying to out-feature Valve's platform, but it was a real, functioning competitor in a space that was just starting to heat up.
The two years that ended with a wrong bet
Impulse was sold to GameStop in 2011, and Kuperman went with it. Two years as the retailer's head of electronic distribution on the PC side. He believed in the project enough to call it his "forever job."
Here's the thing: the people running GameStop at the time weren't the same management team in place today. But whoever was calling the shots made a strategic read on the market that turned out to be spectacularly wrong. Physical retail wasn't going to bounce back. The shift to digital wasn't a trend to wait out. It was the direction the entire industry was heading, and GameStop had a platform already built to ride that wave.
Instead, Impulse was shut down in 2014. The service was quietly killed, and GameStop went back to betting on store shelves and used game margins.
danger
Kuperman's account is based on his personal experience with GameStop's management at the time. The company's current leadership is entirely different from the team that made the decision to abandon digital distribution.
Betting on shelves over servers
The comparison that comes to mind is Blockbuster passing on the chance to acquire Netflix in 2000. Both companies had a front-row seat to the future and chose to look away. Kuperman himself didn't claim Impulse was going to dethrone Steam, but the decision to abandon digital distribution entirely was a different category of mistake.
Why Steam won while everyone else guessed wrong
Kuperman, who went on to a well-regarded second career at Nightdive Studios before retiring recently, has spoken separately about what made Steam so hard to beat. His take, according to his interview with PC Gamer: "What Steam did better than anybody else was to create a community."
That framing matters. Impulse was a store. Steam became a place where people spent time, tracked achievements, reviewed games, and talked to each other. The community layer turned a distribution platform into something stickier and harder to replicate. GameStop, with its focus on physical retail culture, may have understood that kind of community in a store context, but never translated it to the digital space.
What most players miss when looking back at this period is how many real competitors Steam had between 2008 and 2014. Impulse wasn't alone. Platforms like Desura, GamersGate, and eventually the EA Origin client were all trying to carve out space. Most of them either shut down or faded into irrelevance. The ones that survived, like GOG, did so by finding a specific angle (DRM-free games) rather than trying to be a general-purpose Steam alternative.
GameStop had the brand recognition, the publisher relationships, and the installed customer base to make a serious run at digital distribution. The full story of that missed opportunity is worth reading for anyone interested in how the PC gaming market ended up so thoroughly dominated by a single platform.
For more on the business side of gaming and how the industry got to where it is today, make sure to check out more:
