The Nintendo 3DS had one of the most quietly stacked game libraries in handheld history. It launched rough in 2011, took a price cut within months, and then spent the next eight years building a catalog that now looks genuinely untouchable. Nintendo Life recently updated their community-ranked list of the 50 best 3DS games, and the results tell a fascinating story about what players actually valued from the system.
Here's the thing: the top spot went to a port. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D, rebuilt by Grezzo, sits at number one with a near-perfect community score. That says something meaningful about both the original game and the quality of the remake itself.
What the rankings actually reveal
The top 10 is dominated by Zelda and Fire Emblem, which tracks. The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds lands at number 2, Fire Emblem: Awakening at number 3, and The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask 3D at number 4. Animal Crossing: New Leaf sneaks in at number 5, which feels exactly right for a game that consumed thousands of hours from millions of players across its lifespan.
What most players miss when skimming this list is how deep the JRPG representation runs. Atlus alone accounts for six entries across the top 50, including multiple Shin Megami Tensei titles:
- Shin Megami Tensei IV (ranked 15th)
- Shin Megami Tensei IV: Apocalypse (ranked 25th)
- Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey Redux (ranked 24th)
- SMT: Devil Survivor Overclocked (ranked 47th)
- SMT: Devil Survivor 2 Record Breaker (ranked 28th)
- SMT: Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers (ranked 32nd)
That is a remarkable run for a single publisher on a single platform.
info
This list updates dynamically based on Nintendo Life user scores. Rankings can shift over time as more players rate games on the site.
The games that defined the hardware
Kirby: Planet Robobot sits at number 6, which is the correct opinion. It took the solid foundation of Kirby: Triple Deluxe (ranked 22nd) and added a mech suit mechanic that genuinely changed how the game played. HAL Laboratory made the pink ball feel dangerous, and the result is arguably the best Kirby game on any system.
Kid Icarus: Uprising at number 9 remains one of the most ambitious games the 3DS ever produced. The controls were awkward, yes, but the sheer volume of content, the wit in the writing, and the variety of its set pieces put it in a category few games on the system could match.
Metroid: Samus Returns at number 10 is where opinions split. MercurySteam's remake of Metroid II added a melee counter mechanic that divided the fanbase, but the community clearly came down on the side of loving it. The game directly led to Nintendo partnering with the studio on Metroid Dread.
The hidden gems and community surprises
The key here is looking at what ranked lower than expected. Mario Kart 7 sits at just 21st, which feels low for a game that sold over 18 million copies. Super Mario 3D Land lands at 26th. Both are genuinely excellent games that seem undervalued by the community scoring system, possibly because they attract more casual raters.
Shovel Knight at 12th is a pleasant surprise for a third-party eShop title. WayForward's Shantae and the Pirate's Curse at 43rd proves the series had real traction on the platform.
The list also highlights some notable absences. Etrian Odyssey, Tomodachi Life, Ever Oasis, and Stella Glow all failed to crack the top 50, either due to low rating counts or niche appeal keeping scores from reaching the threshold. The community comments on the original article are full of fans pointing this out.
Some games that did make the cut, worth highlighting:
Why this list still matters
The 3DS eShop closed in March 2023, which means physical carts and pre-loaded systems are now the only way to access most of this library. Prices on secondhand hardware have climbed steadily since the discontinuation in September 2020, with complete-in-box units now regularly fetching $150 to $200 or more.
That makes a ranked list like this genuinely useful for anyone deciding where to spend limited budget on a finite and shrinking supply of software. The top 50 covers most of the system's essential experiences, but the real depth sits in the games that just missed the cut.
Pro tip: if you're building a 3DS library now, prioritize physical copies of the Atlus titles and the Dragon Quest ports. Those are the games most likely to appreciate further and hardest to find at reasonable prices. For everything else, browse more guides to find deeper dives into specific franchises and genres worth tracking down. Make sure to check out more:
