Shawn Layden, the former head of PlayStation who spent 32 years at Sony, has a clear message for Microsoft: Xbox needs to pick a lane.
Layden, who helped shape PlayStation from its first console through PS4 and oversaw 13 first-party studios before leaving in 2019, recently posted a pointed comment on LinkedIn suggesting Microsoft's leadership fundamentally misunderstands how the games industry works. The comment was later deleted, but the conversation it sparked is worth having in full.
His core argument is direct: there are two viable roads for Xbox, and they run in opposite directions. Either Microsoft commits to being the biggest game publisher in the world (a goal it is genuinely close to achieving, given the Activision Blizzard and Bethesda acquisitions), or it commits to being a competitive platform holder like PlayStation or Nintendo. The problem is that those two ambitions are structurally at odds with each other.
Get 1-month GTA+ subscription with pre-order.
Pre-Order GTA 6 Now
Two roads that never meet
"To be a platform and to be a very well-supported, well-accepted, well-selling platform, you need exclusive content," Layden explained. Nintendo has Mario and Zelda. PlayStation has Kratos, Horizon, and Astro Bot. Exclusives are the reason someone buys your box over the competition's.
But if you're the world's biggest publisher, exclusivity is almost the last thing you want. You put your games everywhere. Multi-platform reach is the entire point. The more storefronts carrying your titles, the bigger your revenue. Those two business models pull in opposite directions, and Layden's argument is that Microsoft has been trying to walk both paths simultaneously.
He speaks from experience. When running PlayStation Studios, first-party games never exceeded roughly 22 percent of the platform's total business. The other 80 percent came from publishers like EA, Ubisoft, Activision, and Take-Two. His job wasn't to dominate the publishing market; it was to make games that grew the overall pie and gave people a reason to buy a PlayStation specifically.
How Microsoft ended up on both roads at once
The story of how Xbox got here is worth tracing. Microsoft's studio roster used to revolve around a handful of core franchises: Halo, Gears of War, and Forza. Then in 2018, Xbox boss Phil Spencer kicked off an aggressive acquisition run, picking up Playground Games, Ninja Theory, Undead Labs, Compulsion Games, Obsidian Entertainment, inXile Entertainment, and Double Fine in the space of roughly 18 months.
Layden's reaction at the time: "Wow, that's crazy." Sony's approach had always been to acquire studios they'd already worked with extensively, building trust over years before putting a ring on it. Insomniac Games, for example, worked with Sony on and off for 20 years before the acquisition was formalized on the eve of Marvel's Spider-Man.
Microsoft's buying spree then hit a completely different scale. The $7.5bn ZeniMax acquisition in 2020 brought in id Software, Arkane, Bethesda Game Studios, MachineGames, and Tango Gameworks. Then came the $68.7bn Activision Blizzard deal in 2022, a transaction so large it took nearly two years to clear regulatory hurdles due to monopoly concerns. That one deal alone brought Call of Duty, World of Warcraft, and a studio portfolio of roughly 10,000 people under Microsoft's roof.
Partly to satisfy regulators during that process, Microsoft found itself committing to multi-platform publishing. Game Pass was supposed to be the thread tying it all together: a subscription catalogue so broad that users would never want to leave. But as Xbox Series X/S hardware sales slowed, the limited install base became a real problem. By 2024, Microsoft went fully multiplatform, publishing former exclusives on PlayStation and Switch, and telling employees internally that “every screen is an Xbox.”
The cost of not choosing
The consequences of that strategic ambiguity are now visible. Microsoft's recent restructuring, described by the company itself as the most significant in Xbox history, resulted in 3,200 layoffs and the closure or departure of four studios including Double Fine, Compulsion Games, and Ninja Theory. Studios acquired during that 2018 spending spree were among those hit hardest.
New Xbox leader Asha Sharma wrote in her restructuring letter that Xbox now finds itself "competing not only with the largest publishers, but also with smaller independent studios." Layden's response to that framing is essentially: yes, that's what happens when you try to be both things.
He's careful to note he isn't rooting for Xbox to fail. "I prefer the industry when you have two really strong competitors. You get better games, you get more games, and you get an industry riding a positive wave." He uses the Ali vs. Frazier analogy: the competition between those two fighters made the entire sport bigger. The 360 vs. PS3 era generated that same energy for gaming, and that kind of rivalry benefits players on both sides.
His LinkedIn comment, which started all this, came from a broader conversation about what he calls "entertainment DNA," and why companies like Netflix, Amazon, and Google have struggled to make meaningful inroads in gaming despite enormous resources. Technology and money alone don't solve the equation. The companies that succeed in interactive entertainment understand that games are fundamentally an entertainment product, not a software or hardware one. Sony's original PlayStation structure, a joint venture between Sony Electronics and Sony Music, worked precisely because it merged technical capability with entertainment instinct.
Xbox's current bet appears to be swinging back toward exclusivity, with Gears of War: E-Day and inXile's Clockwork Revolution positioned as platform-defining titles. Whether two games can rebuild the kind of platform identity that exclusivity requires is a real question. For players keeping tabs on where Xbox games are landing across platforms, our guide on whether Halo: Campaign Evolved supports crossplay is worth a read as the multiplatform picture continues to shift.
If you're playing on Xbox hardware in the meantime, the ROG Xbox Ally X settings guide covers how to get the best performance out of Microsoft's handheld. For everything else happening across the industry right now, the full gaming guides hub has you covered.
