The Super Mario Bros. 40th anniversary pin set sold out fast the first time around. For anyone who missed it during the MAR10 Day celebrations back in March, My Nintendo has quietly restocked it in North America, and the clock is ticking on limited stock.
Pay less for your games.
Get discounts up to 80% off
What you actually get for 600 Platinum Points
The pin set redeems for 600 Platinum Points and includes two jumbo 2" x 2" collectible pins. One celebrates the Super Mario Galaxy series, and the other marks the Super Mario Bros. 40th anniversary milestone. Both pins are oversized compared to standard collectible pins, which makes them a step above the usual My Nintendo physical rewards.
Here's the thing: 600 Platinum Points is a fairly accessible ask for anyone who regularly buys Nintendo titles or logs into My Nintendo with some consistency. You earn Platinum Points through game purchases, app check-ins, and completing missions on the platform, so most active Nintendo fans should have enough sitting around.
The broader 40th anniversary merch push
The pin set restock is part of a wider wave of Super Mario Bros. 40th anniversary merchandise Nintendo has been rolling out. The My Nintendo Store is also offering a Super Mario Galaxy sticker sheet for 300 Platinum Points, a more wallet-friendly option if you're running low on points.
For those who prefer physical purchases, Nintendo has 40th anniversary t-shirts available in both black and white at $34.99. The shirts are a direct buy rather than a points redemption, so they sit outside the My Nintendo rewards system entirely.
Why this restock matters for collectors
Physical My Nintendo rewards have a mixed history of availability. Some items sell out permanently within hours, others get sporadic restocks over several months. The fact that this pin set is back suggests Nintendo has additional stock to move, but "limited" in Nintendo's language genuinely means limited.
What most players miss with these rewards is that Platinum Points expire. Unused points drop off your account, so sitting on a large balance and waiting for the perfect reward is a losing strategy. A 40th anniversary collectible tied to both the Super Mario Galaxy series and the franchise's broader milestone is about as good a redemption target as My Nintendo typically offers.
For the latest gaming news and browse more guides on everything Nintendo, keep an eye on what else surfaces from the ongoing 40th anniversary celebration. Nintendo has been consistent about rolling out new content and merch through the year, and this restock suggests there's more still to come. Make sure to check out more:
