Skip to main content
Four heroes cross a narrow stone bridge over lava together in the original Minecraft Dungeons.

Minecraft Dungeons 1 vs 2: Which Should You Buy for Couch Co-op?

Minecraft Dungeons 1 vs 2: both do four-player couch co-op on one screen. The differences, prices and which to buy.

Written by
George
Updated
Reading time
6 min
Key takeaways

See more GAMES.GG stories on Google

Advertisement

Minecraft Dungeons 1 vs 2 comes down to price and world. Both do four-player couch co-op, but II has an open, connected world and costs $10 more. I've just been playing the original on Switch with my friend's kid, who's 10, couch co-op on one screen. It's really good.

Key takeaways

  • Both games let up to four players share one screen in couch co-op, with one controller each.
  • The original is $19.99, or $39.99 for the Ultimate Edition with all six DLC. Minecraft Dungeons II is $29.99, or $49.99 for the Deluxe Edition.
  • Minecraft Dungeons II swaps the original's mission select for one connected world, adds jumping, and lets local and online players mix in one party.

What's the difference between Minecraft Dungeons 1 and 2?

The biggest difference is how the world fits together. The original sends you on missions with a clear start and end. Minecraft Dungeons II puts everything in one connected world, with dungeons dotted around it and no loading screens between regions. You get around with Minecart Stations and Teleport Statues.

A few other things changed. You can jump in Minecraft Dungeons II, which you couldn't in the first game. Builds go deeper too, with four armour slots and three talisman slots that add passive bonuses on top of your weapon, armour and artifacts. The story is set after the original. The illagers are back, led by a new Illager High Council, and the fight spreads from the Overworld into a new dimension called the Sift.

What hasn't changed is the kind of game it is. Both are Mojang Studios and Double Eleven games in the Diablo mould: you pick a weapon, collect loot, stack enchantments and fight through crowds of mobs with friends.

Do both games have couch co-op?

Yes. Both support up to four players on one console, sharing one screen, with one controller each. On Switch, Nintendo lists both games as 1 to 4 players on a single system, and Minecraft Dungeons II adds local wireless play for 1 to 4 as well. Neither game splits the screen. Everyone stays on the same view, so you all have to stick together.

The sequel adds mixed co-op. That means two of you on the sofa can team up with friends playing online, in the same party. Minecraft Dungeons II also has matchmaking if you want to find strangers to play with. For the setup, see the Minecraft Dungeons 2 co-op guide.

Both games have crossplay with other platforms, and online play on Switch needs a Nintendo Switch Online membership in both. Couch co-op doesn't.

On PC, both games have local co-op on Steam too, with a controller for each player. Minecraft Dungeons II also supports Steam's Remote Play Together, so a friend can join your local game over the internet without owning a copy themselves.

Why is couch co-op such a big deal on Switch?

As for couch co-op, I think it's something that has been missing, and I think it's the only real thing the Switch or the Switch 2 does better than any other console.

It's also why both games suit a kid and an adult on the same sofa. You don't need a second console or a second copy of the game, just another controller.

How much do Minecraft Dungeons 1 and 2 cost?

Here are the standard prices on the Nintendo eShop and Steam in the US:

EditionPriceWhat you get
Minecraft Dungeons$19.99The base game
Minecraft Dungeons Ultimate Edition$39.99The base game and all six DLC
Minecraft Dungeons II$29.99The base game
Minecraft Dungeons II Deluxe Edition$49.99Four hero skins, the Soul cape, the Blub pet, and DLC 1 and 2 when they come out

The Ultimate Edition's DLC is finished and in your hands straight away: Jungle Awakens, Creeping Winter, Howling Peaks, Flames of the Nether, Hidden Depths and Echoing Void. The Deluxe Edition's two DLC packs are added as they come out, so part of what you pay for is still to come. For more on the editions, see the Minecraft Dungeons 2 editions guide.

If you want it on a physical card, the Switch 2 version of Minecraft Dungeons II is in shops now. Nintendo says the Switch 1 physical edition is due on 10 November 2026. If you have Game Pass on Xbox or PC, you might not need to buy II at all: see the Game Pass guide.

Does the original Minecraft Dungeons work on Switch 2?

Yes. The original is a Switch game, and Nintendo says it runs on Switch 2 with the same behaviour as on Switch. There's no separate Switch 2 edition of it.

Minecraft Dungeons II is sold for both. There's a Switch 2 version and a Switch 1 version, both $29.99, and Mojang lists it on Nintendo Switch 1 and 2, Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5, Windows and Steam. So if your kid still has an original Switch, both games are an option. The download for II is about 6.8 GB on Switch and 6.1 GB on Switch 2.

Is the original Minecraft Dungeons still worth it with a kid?

My friend's kid is 10. He started off carrying me until we had played maybe 10 to 20 minutes and I'd got back into what the buttons were.

Then it became very obvious that whilst he had managed to get through all the levels of the game, I don't think he fully grasped how to do these games properly. I've got hundreds of hours in Path of Exile, Diablo and all of that, and Minecraft Dungeons is just those games again.

I used to think Minecraft Dungeons sucked, and it still controls real janky, but I can see the appeal. If you've played these other games, then they feel better, but I think that's just playing on the Switch, if I'm honest.

That's the thing about the original. A 10-year-old got through every level of it, on the same screen as an adult who'd played far more of these games. It's rated PEGI 7, and it had passed 25 million players by September 2023.

It's also finished. The last update, 1.17, came out in November 2022, so what you buy is what you get. With the Ultimate Edition, that's the whole game and every DLC for $10 more than the sequel's base game.

Should you buy Minecraft Dungeons 1 or 2?

If price is what matters, buy the original. That's what my friend's kid ended up with. His dad didn't want to pay the price for the second one and managed to pick up the first one cheap instead. So I believe if his dad was less tight, he would be playing the second one.

Minecraft Dungeons II is the newer game, with the bigger world, jumping, deeper builds and mixed co-op, and it's getting DLC. The original does the same couch co-op for less, and it still holds up for a kid and an adult on one screen.

If you already own the original, you don't need II just for couch co-op. If you're buying for the first time and don't mind the extra $10, the sequel is the one still being updated. If you go that way, start with the Minecraft Dungeons II beginner's guide.

FAQ

Is Minecraft Dungeons split screen?

No. Both games put up to four local players on one shared screen, with one controller each.

Can you play Minecraft Dungeons 2 couch co-op on Switch 1?

Yes. Minecraft Dungeons II is on Switch 1 and Switch 2, and Nintendo lists both as 1 to 4 players on a single system.

How much more is Minecraft Dungeons 2 than the original?

The base games are $19.99 and $29.99, so $10 more. The original's Ultimate Edition, with all six DLC, is $39.99.

Advertisement